Letter
How to Stop Stopping in Winter
The clocks went back on Sunday, and right on cue, everyone has started talking about January.
"I'll get back on it in the new year."
"No point starting now, not with Christmas coming."
"I'll sort myself out in January."
I hear it every year. And every year it's the same story: eight, nine, ten weeks written off, a few pounds gained, health down the pan and all the momentum lost. Then a frantic restart on the 2nd or 3rd of January, already starting from behind.
It's a running joke that I'm always in my best shape in winter. While everyone else is getting their bikini body ready for summer, I've already got mine, because my natural disposition leans towards autumn and the work I do then carries straight through the winter. Autumn and winter are my seasons. Summer can fuck right off.
It's not that I stop training in summer; it's that I've learned to adapt to the seasons. Do solid work through autumn and winter, and spring and summer become more about maintenance, plus pushing harder when your biology allows it. But that only works if you lay the groundwork in winter, which is exactly what most people don't do.
So instead of trying to be brilliant through winter, I aim for something far more boring; I stop trying to raise my ceiling and start raising my floor.
Why does winter make everything harder?
Two things happen when the nights draw in. I call them the shiny shit and the shitty shit.
The shiny shit is everything that suddenly appears on the calendar. Halloween, Bonfire Night, Diwali, Christmas parties, drinks, dinners, people you haven't seen all year, "we must catch up before Christmas". None of it is bad. But there's more of it, more often, and it all pulls you away from whatever you were building.
The shitty shit is everything that makes you feel rubbish. Some of it is physical: less daylight, colder weather, your body clock lurching when the clocks change, and every bug going round. Some of it is emotional. Christmas drags things up. As we get older we lose people, and if you're dealing with loss, don't get on with your family or you're lonely, the season can feel really heavy.
The physical side is real:
- The clock change hits harder than you'd think. A Danish study covering more than 185,000 hospital contacts found an 11% rise in depression diagnoses straight after the switch from summer time to standard time, which took about 10 weeks to fade (Hansen et al., 2017).
- Your brain works differently by season. Researchers who scanned people across the year found that the brain's responses during attention and memory tasks rise and fall with the seasons (Meyer et al., 2016). Your output isn't meant to look the same in December as it does in June.
- Your vitamin D drops. In the UK, between October and early March we don't make enough vitamin D from sunlight. That's why the NHS says everyone should consider a daily supplement through autumn and winter (NHS).
- For some people, it's more than a dip. Seasonal affective disorder (SAD) is depression that comes and goes with the seasons. Symptoms include persistent low mood, losing interest in things you usually enjoy, being more tired and sleeping more, and being hungrier and eating more (NHS).
So your capacity is lower, your load is higher, and you're trying to run the same plan you ran in July. Can you see why it all falls apart?
Why "I'll start again in January" doesn't work
Stopping isn't free - it carries a cost and most people don’t realise.
In one study, people gained an average of about 0.8 lb (0.37 kg) over the holiday season. That doesn't sound like much. But it was most of what they gained across the whole autumn and winter, and they still hadn't lost it by the following September (Yanovski et al., 2000).
Every year you write off winter, you start the next one slightly further back.
And here's the irony; the research on New Year's resolutions shows that deciding is what matters, not the date. Of people who made a resolution, 46% were still succeeding six months later, compared with just 4% of people who wanted to change but never committed (Norcross et al., 2002).
Most people don't lack clarity in January. They lack commitment, because they've stopped, and it's far harder to get something moving again once it's stopped. If you've ever had to push a broken-down car, you'll know. Once it's rolling, it moves with ease. Let it stop and you're in trouble.
So if deciding is what works, why wait eight weeks to do it?
The bigger problem is the pattern. Progress never comes in a straight line anyway. Often nothing happens for weeks, then everything clicks at once, and it's those weeks of nothing that people can't sit with. When I first started playing golf there was no way I could hit the ball straight and long. A couple of months later I could. I improved fast, then hit a ceiling and watched it all drop off.
Whichever curve you're on - logarithmic or exponential growth - there will be peaks and troughs along the way. And the harder you chase perfection and the more emotionally invested you get, the bigger those swings become. You go all in, hit the ceiling, crash to the floor, get annoyed, go all in again. Stop, start. Stop, start.
Winter just gives you more reasons to fall, and more reasons to "go hard" again afterwards.
Raise the floor, not the ceiling
This is something I learned from one of my mentors, Nic Peterson: raise the floor, not the ceiling.
Your ceiling is you on your best day. Your floor is you on your worst day.
Most high-performing women spend their lives trying to raise the ceiling: be at your best, every day.
And when life gets in the way, they don't adjust; if they can't be at their best, they won't be anything, so they quit. Then they come back swinging a few days later and bounce off the ceiling all over again.
Chasing the ceiling
Best day or no day. The gaps are where it stopped.
Raising the floor
Never your best. Never nothing either.
The dashed line on the right is the floor. It is the one that moves.
But a personal best is a personal best for a reason. You don't hit a PB in the gym every day, so why expect it from everything else?
Instead, aim to do slightly better than your worst. Every day. That's it.
Do that consistently and something interesting happens; your worst days stop being so bad and the floor rises. What used to be an average day becomes your new low. Keep going and the gap between your best and your worst shrinks, until what used to be your best is what you do on autopilot. You've raised the ceiling without ever chasing it.
It's the same idea I wrote about in There Are Two Kinds of Discipline: you don't lift your capacity by chasing your best, you lift it by consistently clearing your worst.
And you don't need a perfect streak. In a well-known study of how habits form, missing a single day didn't significantly affect how the habit built (Lally et al., 2010). The overall pattern is what counts, not an unbroken chain.
Get it right 80% of the time and you'll still see results. It's the on-off, stop-start version that kills progress.
Why it works:
- It's simple. Anyone can do slightly better than their worst.
- It adapts to the day. Got more in the tank? Do more. Running on empty? You still clear the bar.
- It takes the pressure off, which is half the battle for perfectionists.
- It keeps your focus on a handful of things rather than a hundred.
The honest downsides:
- It's boring. Doing less than you're capable of goes against everything high achievers are wired for. We love the underdog, the struggle, the dramatic comeback. Frodo didn't just stroll up Mount Doom and lob the ring in. Raising the floor has no plot twist.
- It compounds slowly. This is a marathon, not a sprint.
- It can feel wrong. I can still hear my dad: "Just do your best." If you were raised on that too, being told slightly better than your worst is enough can cause some proper internal friction.
- It frees up time. I call this freedom danger. If you don't know what to do with free time, it fills itself, or other people fill it for you. Fill it with things you actually want to do.
- It skips the hard stuff. Doing hard things is what builds resilience, so build it in on purpose. Sprinkle in something properly challenging now and then. Just don't make it the whole plan.
How to build your winter plan
Grab a pen and a notebook for this - it means more when it’s written by hand.
- Pick one thing you want to keep moving through winter. A fitness goal, your training, your energy, your sleep, or even just how you want winter to feel.
- Write out your best day for it. Be specific. Say it's fat loss: 10,000 steps, three home-cooked meals, two litres of water, a workout, supplements taken, eight hours' sleep, maybe even a sauna or a massage. That's the peak.
- Write out your worst day. Be honest and keep it realistic, something that could actually happen. Sofa all day, fewer than 500 steps, a takeaway, no training, one glass of water, supplements still in the cupboard.
- Find what sits in the gap. What would slightly better than your worst look like? Maybe it's a 20-minute workout instead of an hour in the gym, one litre of water instead of two, two home-cooked meals and a snack instead of three, seven hours' sleep instead of eight, 8,000 steps instead of 10,000.
- Make that your standard. It's the minimum that still moves you forward. Hit it consistently. If you manage three home-cooked meals one day, brilliant. If you don't, two is enough.
Then ask: is that enough to move me forward? Probably.
Keep the plan at "better than your worst". The moment you turn it into a perfect ten-out-of-ten plan, you're back to chasing the ceiling.
That's what most people do: build the perfect plan, can't stick to it, then get pissed off. In winter, with the shiny shit, the shitty shit and your biology all pulling at you, that's even harder.
The winter basics
The physical side isn't complicated but can make a big difference if you stay on top of it. Pick two or three of these, not all of them:
- Get outside in the morning. Daylight is the strongest signal your body clock gets, and it's in short supply. Even a grey British morning is far brighter than indoor lighting.
- Take your vitamin D. Grey skies mean you're not making much of your own. I take D3 with K2 (the Nutrition Geeks one), but take whichever you like. The NHS says to consider 10 micrograms a day through autumn and winter (NHS).
- Drink more water than you feel like. Cold weather can blunt your thirst by up to 40%, even when you're already dehydrated (Kenefick et al., 2004). Low-grade dehydration feels a lot like low energy.
- Move every day. It doesn't have to be a crazy session. A walk in the cold, all bundled up, counts.
- Protect your sleep. Darker evenings are an advantage here, so use them. I've written a full guide on how to get more deep sleep.
- If winter really flattens you, try a light box. In a review of trials, bright light therapy had a strong effect on seasonal depression (Golden et al., 2005). If you buy one, look for a UV-free lamp of around 10,000 lux.
Enjoy the shiny shit, honour the shitty shit
Raising the floor gives you something most winter plans don't: room.
Room to go to the Christmas party and actually enjoy it, without worrying that it's ruined your diet and everything else.
And room to honour the shitty shit instead of shoving it down, sedating it or white-knuckling past it. If winter brings up grief or heaviness, let it. Feeling it is how you get through it. Suppressing it just turns it into load you carry into January.
Remember that your nervous system works on a seasonal cycle. For most people winter becomes a failure season, but it doesn't have to be.
It's just a different season and we can learn to adapt to it. As I wrote in I Wouldn't Mind a 30% Enlargement, the trick is to flow with the season rather than fight it.
So this year, don't write off November and December, and definitely don't wait for January.
Just do slightly better than your worst. Then do it again tomorrow, and the day after, and the day after that.
If you want more of this, sign up for the Dangerous Dispatch at celestecurrie.com. It's free, and you'll get a digital copy of the Dangerous Woman book, access to the Dangerous Den and my near-daily emails on fitness, fighting, frequency and the fundamentals.
-Celeste
This article is for information only and isn't medical advice. If you're struggling with your mood, speak to your GP.
References
- Hansen BT, Sønderskov KM, Hageman I, Dinesen PT, Østergaard SD (2017). Daylight savings time transitions and the incidence rate of unipolar depressive episodes. Epidemiology. Abstract
- Meyer C et al. (2016). Seasonality in human cognitive brain responses. PNAS. Abstract
- NHS. Vitamin D. Page
- NHS. Seasonal affective disorder (SAD). Page
- Yanovski JA et al. (2000). A prospective study of holiday weight gain. New England Journal of Medicine. NIH release
- Norcross JC, Mrykalo MS, Blagys MD (2002). Auld lang syne: success predictors, change processes, and self-reported outcomes of New Year's resolvers and nonresolvers. Journal of Clinical Psychology. Abstract
- Lally P, van Jaarsveld C, Potts H, Wardle J (2010). How are habits formed: modelling habit formation in the real world. European Journal of Social Psychology. UCL release
- Kenefick RW et al. (2004). Dehydration and rehydration effects on thirst and vasopressin in the cold. Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise. Release
- Golden RN et al. (2005). The efficacy of light therapy in the treatment of mood disorders: a review and meta-analysis of the evidence. American Journal of Psychiatry. Abstract