Celeste

Letter

You Can't Fix Sleep by Attacking It

As promised in the Dispatch: all the science, zero vomit.

I'll be honest; I’ve never been a great sleeper. When I get stressed, overload my nervous system and neglect the basics, my sleep is the first thing to go. When I get on top of it, everything else starts to improve. And as soon as I stop doing the things that work, it all goes to shit again.

So this isn't coming from someone who sleeps like a baby and can't understand why you don't.

It's coming from someone who has had to work at it, tried most of what's on the shelf, and figured out the bit that most sleep advice skips:

You can't fix sleep by attacking it.

Most people go after sleep directly; Another app, another supplement, another rule about what time the phone goes away. Sometimes it helps a bit, but mostly it doesn’t because it just reduces system reliability.

The better question isn't "how do I sleep better?" It's: What's stopping my system from switching off?

Fix the entry to sleep and, over time, the sleep fixes itself.

Why does deep sleep matter so much?

Sleep is rest. Deep sleep is recovery. It's the stage where your body does its overnight service, and if you're skimping on it, you're running on borrowed capacity.

When you’re sleeping:

  • Your brain takes the bins out. In a 2013 study in mice, the space between brain cells expanded by around 60% during sleep, letting fluid flush through and clear waste, including the beta-amyloid linked to Alzheimer's, faster than when awake (Xie et al., 2013). Mice aren't people (I think?), but it's one of the most important findings in sleep science of the last 20 years.
  • Your body repairs itself. Growth hormone is released mainly during deep sleep. In one study of 149 men, deep sleep dropped from around 19% of the night in young adults to just 3% by midlife, and growth hormone fell right alongside it (Van Cauter et al., 2000). That's tissue repair, muscle maintenance and healthy ageing.
  • Your body composition depends on it. In one study, dieters sleeping 5.5 hours lost 55% less fat than those sleeping 8.5 hours on the same diet, and lost 60% more lean mass instead (Nedeltcheva et al., 2010). Same food, same effort, worse result.
  • Your emotional regulation depends on it. After one night without sleep, the brain's threat centre (the amygdala) was more than 60% more reactive to negative images (Yoo et al., 2007). If you've ever snapped at someone over nothing after a bad night, that's why.

And the kicker: you probably don't know how tired you are.

When people were restricted to 6 hours a night for two weeks, their performance dropped to the level of someone who'd been awake for up to two nights straight, yet they barely noticed. Their sleepiness ratings hardly moved after the first few days (Van Dongen et al., 2003).

Which is exactly what high-performing women do; we adapt to the deficit, call it normal, and keep going. It's compensation, and compensation costs.

Why do women struggle with sleep more?

Women are around 41% more likely to experience insomnia than men, and the gap widens with age (Zhang & Wing, 2006).

Part of that is load. If you're the person everything comes back to (work, family, the household, everyone else's problems), you're carrying more into bed with you.

Part of it is biology. We don't just run on a 24-hour clock. We have longer rhythms too: the menstrual cycle, and the seasons. Your sleep, energy and mood shift across the month and across the year, and if you expect identical output every night, you'll keep deciding something's wrong with you when it's just your biology doing what it's always done.

(I've written more about the seasonal side in I Wouldn't Mind a 30% Enlargement.)

Why can't I switch off at night?

Because your nervous system doesn't feel safe enough to let go.

Think about it from your system's point of view; why would it drop into deep sleep if it thinks there's a threat? It won't. It'll keep one eye open, which is why so many of us lie there tired but wired, or drift off fine and then wake at 3am with our brain on overload.

Over the years I've picked this up from coaches, sleep researchers, a lot of reading and a lot of bad nights of my own, and it always comes back to the same thing; whatever is keeping you up, is a sign your system is still busy with something.

It usually falls into one of four camps:

  1. Still searching. You're not worrying, but you are restless. One more episode, one more scroll, one more anything. Your system wants input and won't settle without it.
  2. Still processing. You're the overthinker. Replaying conversations, solving tomorrow's problems, planning next week’s events. You've got open loops and your brain won't stop circling them.
  3. Still carrying. You've held everything together all day and you arrive at bed exhausted but switched on. Tired and wired, with the whole day still sitting in your body.
  4. Still recovering. You sleep, but you wake up feeling like you haven't. Achy, inflamed, catching every bug going. Your system is so far in debt that the night goes on damage control instead of recovery.
Which one is keeping you up

Still searching

One more episode, one more scroll. Restless rather than worried.

Still processing

Replaying conversations, solving tomorrow. Open loops, circling.

Still carrying

Exhausted but switched on. The whole day still sitting in your body.

Still recovering

You sleep and wake up feeling like you didn't. The night goes on damage control.

Most people sit mainly in one, with a bit of another. Knowing which one is yours matters, because it changes what you do about it - I’ll show you how below.

Enjoying this? Here's a shameless bribe...

If you sign up for The Dangerous Dispatch you'll get near-daily emails on fitness, fighting, fundamentals and frequency. Plus you'll also get a digital copy of The Dangerous Woman and the Dangerous Den app, loaded with training across all four pillars. It's worth it, trust me.

  • The Dispatch itself, near-daily, direct to your inbox
  • The Dangerous Den app, loaded with training across all four pillars
  • A digital copy of The Dangerous Woman

Your details go no further. Privacy policy.

The boring basics (that actually work)

Before the clever stuff, the big, boring stuff. Nobody wants to hear these because they're boring and they already know it, but they're boring because they work and chances are you don’t do them even though you know them.

Wake up at the same time every day. Wake time matters more than bedtime. In a study of over 60,000 people, the most regular sleepers had a 20-48% lower risk of dying early, and regularity predicted it better than how long people slept (Windred et al., 2023). Shifting your sleep at the weekend creates "social jetlag", which affects around two-thirds of people and is linked to a higher BMI (Roenneberg et al., 2012). That's why Monday feels like a hangover. As if Mondays weren’t bad enough.

Get daylight in the morning. Ten to twenty minutes outside within the first hour of waking, even under a grey British sky. Morning light sets your body clock, lets cortisol peak when it should (early) and times your melatonin for the evening. In one study, people whose first real light exposure came later in the day woke more often that night, and brighter daytime light was followed by more deep sleep (Wams et al., 2017).

Move during the day. Movement builds sleep pressure, the drive that makes you want to sleep. Ever notice that a day of doing nothing leaves you wide awake at midnight? That's why. Just keep the really intense sessions away from bedtime, because they leave adrenaline and cortisol hanging around when you're trying to wind down.

Keep the room cool, dark and quiet. Heat increases wakefulness and cuts both deep and REM sleep (Okamoto-Mizuno & Mizuno, 2012). Around 18°C is the usual recommendation (Sleep Foundation). Blackout blinds, an open window, earplugs if you need them.

Cut the caffeine off earlier than you think. Caffeine taken 6 hours before bed cut sleep by more than an hour, and people didn't notice the difference (Drake et al., 2013). And it often doesn't stop you falling asleep; it just quietly wrecks the quality, so you don't connect the two.

Full confession: I'm terrible at this. I teach in the evenings, and after a full day of work it's very tempting to reach for a coffee to get me through. I’ve worked hard to cut this down and it has helped long term.

Be honest about alcohol. A drink makes you fall asleep faster, which is why people think it helps. But it disrupts the second half of the night and, at moderate doses and above, cuts REM sleep (Ebrahim et al., 2013). Falling asleep quickly and sleeping well are not the same thing.

Put the phone away an hour before bed. Phones are a constant drip of stimulation. Reading on a light-emitting screen before bed suppressed melatonin, pushed the body clock later and left people groggier the next morning compared with reading a paper book (Chang et al., 2015).

You don't need to be perfect with any of this. Hit these around 80% of the time and you'll see results.

How to get more deep sleep

This is the simplest thing I’ve found that works based on your predisposition:

  1. Pick a trigger. One thing that tells your system "we're going to bed now." Brushing your teeth, dimming the lights, a herbal tea, taking your supplements.
  2. Remove your biggest blocker. Not all of them, just the main thing you do that messes with your sleep. Doomscrolling will be a big one for most people.
  3. Stack up to three things that match your predisposition.
  • Still searching: a warm shower or bath, slow stretching, a gentle walk, slow breathing. Keep hard training and anything exciting away from the evening. You're bringing the system down so it stops hunting for input.
  • Still processing: a brain dump on paper (getting it out, not solving it), gratitude, and fiction that doesn't light your brain up. Close your open loops earlier in the evening by reviewing the day and planning tomorrow, so none of it is living in your head. No research, no planning and no YouTube rabbit holes in bed. I still think the CIA killed JFK.
  • Still carrying: heat and something physical rather than more thinking. A warm bath, legs up the wall, slow breathing. Your body is holding the load, so give it a physical way out.
  • Still recovering: a protein-rich evening meal (not a midnight snack), 10-15 minutes of gentle mobility on the edge of the bed, and proper hydration through the day.

Why heat? Because a warm bath or shower draws heat to your skin, and that makes your core temperature drop, which is one of the signals your body uses to start sleep. A meta-analysis found that a warm bath or shower (40-42.5°C) taken 1-2 hours before bed, for as little as 10 minutes, helped people fall asleep faster and rate their sleep better (Haghayegh et al., 2019).

Cold showers do the opposite at night: they ramp you up. Plus, who actually likes being cold??

Geralt of Rivia raising a tankard with a small, knowing smile.

You didn't sign up yet? Fine...

Not only will I give you the near-daily emails, Dangerous Woman Book and Dangerous Den, but I'll also throw in something extra. You'll see what it is on the next page once you've put your name and email in. It's really cool. Promise.

  • The Dispatch itself, near-daily, direct to your inbox
  • The Dangerous Den app, loaded with training across all four pillars
  • A digital copy of The Dangerous Woman

Your details go no further. Privacy policy.

Do sleep supplements actually work?

The clue's in the name. A supplement is something you add on, not something that replaces the basics. When you're exhausted it's tempting to look for a pill, and I get it. I've tried most of them.

My take:

  • Magnesium is the one I come back to. The evidence is promising rather than rock solid. In older adults, 500 mg a day for eight weeks improved sleep time and time to fall asleep (Abbasi et al., 2012). A review found people fell asleep about 17 minutes faster, but the quality of the evidence was low (Mah & Pitre, 2021). It's cheap and well tolerated. Personally I've found magnesium on its own works better for me than ZMA (the magnesium and zinc combination).
  • L-theanine (the calming amino acid in green tea) and glycine are often paired with magnesium for people who can't switch their brain off.
  • Melatonin is prescription-only in the UK, and I'd treat it more like a medication than a supplement.
  • Tart cherry, chamomile, valerian and lavender are gentle and worth a try. I've even tried blue lotus, which was meant to be great for sleep and dreams. I noticed absolutely nothing.

Whatever you try, give it at least a month, not a week. And if you're on any medication or have a health condition, check with your GP or pharmacist first.

Supplements don't give you great sleep. At best, they prime your system so it has a better chance.

Should you track your sleep?

Tracking is useful as an experiment and useless as an obsession.

I used to wear an Oura ring and loved it, right up until the battery gave up. The data is handy for testing things: try one change for a couple of weeks, see if your deep sleep or heart rate variability moves, keep it if it does, ditch it if it doesn't.

But if checking your sleep score every morning makes you anxious about your sleep, you're adding load, not removing it. You'll know it's working because you'll wake up feeling better, a number just confirms it.

Is hitting snooze bad for you?

It depends on you. A 2023 study of habitual snoozers found that 30 minutes of snoozing didn't harm mood or sleepiness, and thinking performance was the same or slightly better (Sundelin et al., 2023).

It doesn't work for me. Drifting back off just leaves me groggier than if I'd got straight up, that heavy, foggy feeling called sleep inertia.

So test it. Spend a week getting straight up, then a week snoozing, and notice how you feel an hour after waking. Keep whichever wins.

But if you need three alarms to get out of bed every day, the snooze button isn't the problem - your sleep is.

Sleep is a skill, not a luxury

In my definition of a Dangerous Woman, one of the first things on the list is that she can have a bad day and still get a decent night's sleep because she has command of her nervous system, meaning she can up or downregulate it at will.

That's a trainable skill and it starts with the boring basics - which funnily enough, is where all skill building starts.

Happy napping.

-Celeste

If you want more of this, sign up for the Dangerous Dispatch at celestecurrie.com. You'll get a free copy of the Dangerous Woman book, access to the Dangerous Den and my near-daily emails on fitness, fighting, frequency and the fundamentals.

This article is for information only and isn't medical advice. If you have ongoing sleep problems, speak to your GP.

References

  1. Xie L et al. (2013). Sleep drives metabolite clearance from the adult brain. Science. Press release. This study was in mice.
  2. Van Cauter E, Leproult R, Plat L (2000). Age-related changes in slow wave sleep and REM sleep and relationship with growth hormone and cortisol levels in healthy men. JAMA. Journal page
  3. Nedeltcheva AV et al. (2010). Insufficient sleep undermines dietary efforts to reduce adiposity. Annals of Internal Medicine. Journal page
  4. Yoo SS et al. (2007). The human emotional brain without sleep. Current Biology. Press release
  5. Van Dongen HPA et al. (2003). The cumulative cost of additional wakefulness. Sleep. Journal page
  6. Zhang B, Wing YK (2006). Sex differences in insomnia: a meta-analysis. Sleep. Abstract
  7. Windred DP et al. (2023). Sleep regularity is a stronger predictor of mortality risk than sleep duration. Sleep. UK Biobank summary
  8. Roenneberg T et al. (2012). Social jetlag and obesity. Current Biology. Press release
  9. Wams EJ et al. (2017). Linking light exposure and subsequent sleep. Sleep. Journal page
  10. Okamoto-Mizuno K, Mizuno K (2012). Effects of thermal environment on sleep and circadian rhythm. Journal of Physiological Anthropology. Abstract
  11. Sleep Foundation. Best temperature for sleep. Page
  12. Drake C et al. (2013). Caffeine effects on sleep taken 0, 3, or 6 hours before going to bed. Journal of Clinical Sleep Medicine. AASM release
  13. Ebrahim IO et al. (2013). Alcohol and sleep I: effects on normal sleep. Alcoholism: Clinical & Experimental Research. Press release
  14. Chang AM et al. (2015). Evening use of light-emitting eReaders negatively affects sleep, circadian timing, and next-morning alertness. PNAS. Harvard release
  15. Haghayegh S et al. (2019). Before-bedtime passive body heating by warm shower or bath to improve sleep. Sleep Medicine Reviews. Abstract
  16. Abbasi B et al. (2012). The effect of magnesium supplementation on primary insomnia in elderly. Journal of Research in Medical Sciences. PubMed
  17. Mah J, Pitre T (2021). Oral magnesium supplementation for insomnia in older adults: a systematic review and meta-analysis. BMC Complementary Medicine and Therapies. Journal page
  18. Sundelin T et al. (2023). Is snoozing losing? Journal of Sleep Research. Wiley release

The Dangerous Dispatch

Near-daily letters on fitness, fighting, frequency and nervous system fundamentals. It comes with the Dangerous Den app and a copy of The Dangerous Woman.

  • The Dispatch itself, near-daily, direct to your inbox
  • The Dangerous Den app, loaded with training across all four pillars
  • A digital copy of The Dangerous Woman

Your details go no further. Privacy policy.

Hang on.

Before you disappear, take the Dispatch with you.

The Dangerous Dispatch

Near-daily letters on fitness, fighting, frequency and nervous system fundamentals. It comes with the Dangerous Den app and a copy of The Dangerous Woman.

  • The Dispatch itself, near-daily, direct to your inbox
  • The Dangerous Den app, loaded with training across all four pillars
  • A digital copy of The Dangerous Woman

Your details go no further. Privacy policy.

You'll get an email to confirm. If it isn't in your inbox within 10 minutes, look in spam, junk and promotions.