Letter
Appreciation beats praise
Last week I received a card; a really thoughtful, handwritten card from a junior coach leaving for university.
If I had feelings, I would have shed a tear over it - that’s how nice it was.
The line that stood out the most though, was this:
‘Thanks for keeping my ego in check’
It’s true - anytime he would mess up I’d tell him to get in the bin. It became a running joke and it still makes me smile now. It was light hearted but it was also a call out, because if nobody calls you out and all you ever get is praise, you don’t learn, you don’t grow and you definitely don’t become the sort of person I’d label as ‘dangerous.’
Praise is given too freely nowadays and it shows. Self entitlement, idleness, inability to fail; a real recipe for mediocrity. The bar for greatness has never been lower and it’s frustrating to see. Trophies and medals for showing up, celebrations for completing the most mundane of tasks.
Emptying the bin and expecting praise for it. Appreciation, yes absolutely. But praise? For functioning like a human and doing something normal and necessary?
No.
As my parents would say:
‘What do you want, a medal?’
There’s a balance with this - too little praise and you question your worth. But too much - like what’s running rampant today - leads to arrogance and undeserved self-assurance which either crumbles at the first sign of anything difficult, or leads to delusions and dissonance whenever questioned or challenged.
You get put on a pedestal, you’ll end up falling, or being knocked off it.
Now don’t get this twisted; it’s not about being a dick and treating people badly. It’s about knowing when to praise vs when to show appreciation.
I will always make a point of thanking people and making it clear I’ve noticed when they’ve done something useful, but I’m not going to praise you for wiping your own ass. I’ll praise you when you’ve done something difficult and beyond the norm (which is variable person to person).
Too much of anything makes it meaningless.
As with most things, it comes back to balance.
-Celeste